Propane Tank Refill Cost: What It Costs to Fill Every Tank Size (2026)
Fill costs at the national average ($2.82/gal) with cheapest and most expensive state ranges. Based on the 80% fill rule.
Source: EIA SHOPP residential propane survey. Week ending 16 November 2026. Refreshed 19 November 2026.
How much does it cost to fill a propane tank? At the national average of $2.82/gallon (November 2026), filling a 500-gallon tank costs about $1,127 (400 usable gallons under the 80% fill rule), a 250-gallon tank about $563, a 1,000-gallon tank about $2,254, and a 20 lb BBQ cylinder about $20.92 at U-Haul's median posted refill price (18 November 2026). State prices swing the 500-gallon fill from about $716 in Iowa to $2,067 in Florida. To price a top-up from your own gauge reading, use the cost to fill a 500-gallon propane tank calculator.
For tank-size-specific refill cost guides (with retailer matrices for the cylinder sizes and bobtail-delivery math for the home-tank sizes), see our dedicated reference site.
propanetankrefillcost.com →Propane Tank Fill Costs at a Glance (2026)
| Tank Size | Total Capacity | Usable (80% Rule) | Fill Cost (Nat. Avg $2.82) | Iowa $1.79/gal | Florida $5.17/gal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 lb BBQ | ~5 gal | ~4.7 gal | $13 | $8 | $24 |
| 30 lb portable | ~7 gal | ~5.6 gal | $16 | $10 | $29 |
| 40 lb portable | ~9.4 gal | ~7.5 gal | $21 | $13 | $39 |
| 100 lb cylinder | ~23.6 gal | ~18.9 gal | $53 | $34 | $98 |
| 120 gallon | 120 gal | 96 gal | $270 | $172 | $496 |
| 250 gallon | 250 gal | 200 gal | $563 | $358 | $1,033 |
| 500 gallon | 500 gal | 400 gal | $1,127 | $716 | $2,067 |
| 1,000 gallon | 1,000 gal | 800 gal | $2,254 | $1,432 | $4,134 |
Prices based on 80% fill rule (industry standard and NFPA 58 requirement). Actual fill may vary by supplier. 20lb tank usable capacity is the full 20 lbs for refill; exchange gives approximately 15 lbs.
Cost to Fill a 500-Gallon Tank by State (November 2026)
EIA residential price per gallon × 400 usable gallons (the 80% fill rule). EIA's figure is the average price homes in the state paid that week, so your own quote can sit above or below it.
| State | Price/gal | 500-gal fill (400 usable) |
|---|---|---|
| Iowa | $1.79 | $716 |
| Ohio | $2.81 | $1,126 |
| Louisiana | $3.09 | $1,236 |
| Texas | $3.21 | $1,284 |
| Pennsylvania | $3.27 | $1,308 |
| New York | $3.82 | $1,529 |
| Florida | $5.17 | $2,067 |
See full pricing for all 50 states, or today's propane prices for the daily wholesale benchmark and live state summer surveys. Source: EIA Heating Oil & Propane Survey.
What People Actually Pay to Fill a 500-Gallon Tank
Forum threads on this question usually quote a single number without the context that moves it by hundreds of dollars. Three things decide your real bill:
- How empty the tank is. A 500-gallon tank holds 400 usable gallons. A fill from near-empty is ~380-400 gallons ($1,127 at the national average); a top-off from a quarter full is closer to 300 gallons.
- Your state. The same 400-gallon fill runs about $716 in Iowa versus $2,067 in Florida, a swing of $1,351 on the same tank.
- Will-call vs auto-delivery. Some suppliers charge extra for an order you place yourself or for an out-of-hours run: Midwest Energy & Communications publishes a $25 fee on every will-call delivery, and Suburban Propane lists will-call and emergency delivery fees without publishing the amounts. Ask for every fee in writing alongside the per-gallon price.
Bottom line: a full 400-gallon fill comes to $1,127 at the national average of $2.82/gal, before any delivery fees. Check the current price in your state before you order.
20 lb BBQ Tank: Refill vs Exchange
For BBQ and patio heater owners, a refill at a posted per-gallon price usually beats the exchange cages at Walmart, Home Depot and gas stations, because a refill puts in the full 20 lb and Blue Rhino and AmeriGas exchange cylinders hold 15 lb. Only sellers that post prices online get a figure below.
| Option | Posted price | Propane Amount | Per pound | Where Available |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| U-Haul refill (median) | $20.92 ($19.74-$21.86 middle half) | 20 lb, 4.7 gal | $1.05 | 108 U-Haul locations, 20 metros, read 18 November 2026 |
| U-Haul exchange | $24.95 | Not stated | - | U-Haul exchange-only stores |
| Blue Rhino Delivery+ exchange | $29.99 + tax | 15 lb | $2.00 | Delivered to the door where offered |
| Costco, Tractor Supply, dealers | Not posted online | 20 lb (full) | - | Ask the per-gallon price, multiply by 4.7 |
| Exchange cages (Walmart, Home Depot, Lowe's) | Not posted online | 15 lb | - | Blue Rhino or AmeriGas |
Residential Tank Fill Details
The 80% Fill Rule: Why Your Tank Is Never Completely Filled
Propane tanks are filled to only 80% of their total capacity. This is required by NFPA 58 (the Liquefied Petroleum Gas Code) and is not a supplier trying to shortchange you. Propane liquid expands significantly with temperature changes - up to 17 times the volume of the liquid. The 20% vapor space (called the outage) allows for this expansion without creating a dangerous pressure buildup.
All modern tanks have an OPD valve (Overfill Protection Device) that automatically stops filling at 80%. This is why your 500-gallon tank only ever holds about 400 usable gallons, and why the fill costs above are calculated on the usable capacity.
Learn more about propane safety and tank requirementsDelivery Fees and Pricing Models
Suburban Propane lists each of these fee types on its fees and charges page without amounts; Midwest Energy & Communications (Michigan) publishes its will-call fee. Both read 20 November 2026. Ask any supplier for its fee list with the quote.