PropaneCostPerGallon.com is an independent resource. We are not a propane supplier, and no supplier can pay to change our prices. Prices are estimates based on EIA data.

20 lb Propane Tank Cost: Refill vs Exchange Prices (2026)

A full 20 lb refill came to $20.92 at the median U-Haul posted price of $4.45 a gallon (108 locations, read 18 November 2026). Exchange cylinders hold less: Blue Rhino fills 15 lb.

Refill, U-Haul median
$20.92
Full 20 lb, middle half $19.74-$21.86
Exchange, U-Haul
$24.95
Blue Rhino delivered $29.99 for 15 lb

Refill vs Exchange: Side-by-Side Comparison

FactorRefillExchange
Posted price$20.92 (U-Haul median, 4.7 gal)$24.95 at U-Haul; $29.99 Blue Rhino delivered
Propane amount20 lb (full)15 lb (Blue Rhino's stated net fill)
Per pound$1.05$2.00 (Blue Rhino delivered)
Your TankKeep your own tankSwap for a different tank
Accepts Old/Expired TanksNo - must be in good conditionYes - great for expired tanks
At the storeAn attendant fills and weighs your tankA staff member swaps it from the cage
AvailabilityPropane dealers, U-Haul, some hardwareWalmart, Home Depot, most gas stations
Bottom line: At these posted prices a refill costs about half as much per pound as a delivered Blue Rhino exchange ($1.05 against $2.00). Exchange earns its place when your tank is out of date or damaged, or when you want it brought to the door.

Where to Refill or Exchange: Posted Prices

Only sellers that post a price on their own website get a figure here. The rest set prices store by store and do not publish them, so the table says so rather than guess.

SellerTypePosted priceNotes
U-HaulRefill$4.45/gal median ($3.75-$5.80)Posted per gallon on each location page. 108 locations in 20 metros, read 18 November 2026. A full 20 lb tank: about $20.92.
U-HaulExchange$24.95 eachAll 11 exchange-only U-Haul stores read listed this price. Fill weight not stated.
Blue Rhino Delivery+Exchange$29.99 + taxDelivered to your door where offered. 15 lb net fill. A spare filled tank with no exchange: $69.99.
Costco, Tractor Supply, AceRefillNot posted onlineSet by each store. Ask for the per-gallon price and multiply by 4.7.
Walmart, Home Depot, Lowe's, gas stationsExchangeNot posted onlineBlue Rhino or AmeriGas cages. Both brands cut their fill from 17 lb to 15 lb in 2008, which the FTC alleged was a disguised price rise (settled 2014).
Local propane dealerRefillNot posted onlineMany fill cylinders at the yard. Ring for the per-gallon price.

How we priced this: U-Haul "Propane near" results pages for 20 metros (for example Dallas), every location price listed at propanetankrefillcost.com; Blue Rhino Delivery+; FTC matter 111-0195. Read 18 November 2026, prices before sales tax. A full 20 lb tank is taken as 4.7 gallons (20 lb at about 4.24 lb a gallon), so a fill = 4.7 x the per-gallon price.

How Long Does a 20 lb Tank Last?

A full tank holds about 430,000 BTU (20 lb x 21,548 BTU per pound, PERC pocket guide). Hours = 430,000 / your appliance's BTU rating. Burners on medium draw less, so they last longer than these full-output times.

10,000 BTU/hr at full outputabout 43 hours
20,000 BTU/hr at full outputabout 22 hours
30,000 BTU/hr at full outputabout 14 hours
40,000 BTU/hr at full outputabout 11 hours
50,000 BTU/hr at full outputabout 9 hours

Buying a Tank

Blue Rhino Delivery+ lists a filled spare tank with no exchange at $69.99 plus tax (read 18 November 2026). Hardware and home stores sell empty tanks and pre-filled exchange tanks at prices set store by store. An empty tank needs a refill before first use; at the U-Haul median that adds about $20.92.

When buying new: check that the valve is OPD-compliant (required since 2002). Look for the triangular handwheel on the valve - that indicates OPD compliance.

20 lb Tank Expiration and Recertification

Every propane tank has a manufacture date stamped on the collar (the metal ring at the top). This date is in MM/YY format - for example, "04/13" means April 2013. Tanks expire 12 years after this date and cannot be refilled until recertified.

Recertification StageWhenWhere
First recertification12 years after manufacture datePropane dealers that requalify cylinders (ask their charge first)
Subsequent recertificationsEvery 5 years after first recertSame as above
Tank replacementIf recertification fails or costs more than a new tankExchange cages take the old tank

If your tank is near expiration, the exchange program is a smart option - they accept expired tanks and give you a freshly recertified one. Just be aware you are paying more per pound of propane for that convenience.

Propane tank safety rules and storage requirements

Tips to Save on 20 lb Propane

Ask for the per-gallon price

Refill stations charge by the gallon. U-Haul's posted prices ran from $3.75 to $5.80 a gallon, so it pays to compare two or three nearby.

Refill rather than exchange

Unless your tank is out of date, a refill puts in 20 lb; an exchange tank holds 15 lb.

Buy multiple tanks

Keeping 2 tanks means you can refill both at once and never run out mid-cook. Buy when on sale at season start.

Check tare weight before filling

If a tank is near empty (close to TW on collar), you will get more value from a full refill than topping off.

20 lb Tank FAQ

How much does it cost to refill a 20 lb propane tank?
A full 20 lb tank holds about 4.7 gallons. U-Haul posts its refill price per gallon on every location page: across 108 locations in 20 metros read on 18 November 2026, the median was $4.45 a gallon, so a full refill came to about $20.92 before tax. The middle half of those locations put it between $19.74 and $21.86. Costco, Tractor Supply, Walmart, Home Depot and Ace post no propane price online, so ask the store for its per-gallon price and multiply by 4.7.
Is a propane tank exchange worth it?
Usually not on price. Blue Rhino states a 15 lb net fill and lists its Delivery+ exchange at $29.99 plus tax (18 November 2026), about $2.00 per pound delivered. A full 20 lb refill at the U-Haul median comes to about $1.05 per pound. U-Haul's own exchange-only stores listed $24.95 a tank but do not state the fill weight. Exchange makes sense when your tank is past its requalification date or damaged: the exchange cage takes it, a refill station will not fill it.
How long does a 20 lb propane tank last on a BBQ grill?
A full 20 lb tank holds about 430,000 BTU (20 lb x 21,548 BTU per pound, from the Propane Education & Research Council's pocket guide). Divide that by your grill's BTU rating to get hours at full output: a 30,000 BTU grill runs about 14 hours flat out, and longer on medium because the burners draw less. The BTU rating is on the grill's data plate or in its manual.
When does a 20 lb propane tank expire?
Propane tanks have a 12-year life from their manufacture date before they require recertification. The manufacture date is stamped on the collar of the tank in month/year format (e.g., '06/14' means June 2014). After the initial 12 years, tanks can be recertified for an additional 5-year period, then 5 years at a time. Propane dealers that requalify cylinders set their own charge, so ask for it before you take the tank in; an exchange cage will also take an out-of-date tank.
What is the cheapest place to refill a 20 lb propane tank?
Compare per-gallon prices, because that is how refill stations charge. U-Haul's posted prices on 18 November 2026 ran from $3.75 to $5.80 a gallon across 108 locations, so two stations in one city can differ by several dollars a fill. Costco, Tractor Supply and local propane dealers do not post prices online: ring and ask for the per-gallon price, then multiply by 4.7 for a full 20 lb tank. Any refill at a posted per-gallon price is likely to beat an exchange, which puts back 15 lb.
How do I know when my 20 lb propane tank is empty?
The most reliable method is to weigh the tank. A standard empty 20 lb tank weighs 17 to 18 lbs (called the tare weight, stamped on the collar as TW). If the tank weighs about the same as the TW figure, it is empty. Pour warm water down the side of the tank and feel for where the tank goes cold - that is the liquid level. A gauge that fits between the valve and the regulator also works.
All tank refill costs|Tank safety guide

Spotted an out-of-date price, or have a propane question?

A real person reads every message. Tell us if something on this page looks wrong, or ask anything about propane pricing, tanks, or suppliers.

Ask us or flag a correction

Or email questions@propanecostpergallon.com. With your permission we may publish an anonymised version of your question and our answer. General information, not professional advice.

How this site is paid for: when you ask for quotes, we pass your request to up to three local suppliers, and they may pay us for the introduction. Our prices and dealer listings do not depend on that. They come from EIA and state sources, and no supplier can pay to change them.