20 lb Propane Tank Cost: Refill vs Exchange Prices (2026)
A full 20 lb refill came to $20.92 at the median U-Haul posted price of $4.45 a gallon (108 locations, read 18 November 2026). Exchange cylinders hold less: Blue Rhino fills 15 lb.
Refill vs Exchange: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Refill | Exchange |
|---|---|---|
| Posted price | $20.92 (U-Haul median, 4.7 gal) | $24.95 at U-Haul; $29.99 Blue Rhino delivered |
| Propane amount | 20 lb (full) | 15 lb (Blue Rhino's stated net fill) |
| Per pound | $1.05 | $2.00 (Blue Rhino delivered) |
| Your Tank | Keep your own tank | Swap for a different tank |
| Accepts Old/Expired Tanks | No - must be in good condition | Yes - great for expired tanks |
| At the store | An attendant fills and weighs your tank | A staff member swaps it from the cage |
| Availability | Propane dealers, U-Haul, some hardware | Walmart, Home Depot, most gas stations |
Where to Refill or Exchange: Posted Prices
Only sellers that post a price on their own website get a figure here. The rest set prices store by store and do not publish them, so the table says so rather than guess.
| Seller | Type | Posted price | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| U-Haul | Refill | $4.45/gal median ($3.75-$5.80) | Posted per gallon on each location page. 108 locations in 20 metros, read 18 November 2026. A full 20 lb tank: about $20.92. |
| U-Haul | Exchange | $24.95 each | All 11 exchange-only U-Haul stores read listed this price. Fill weight not stated. |
| Blue Rhino Delivery+ | Exchange | $29.99 + tax | Delivered to your door where offered. 15 lb net fill. A spare filled tank with no exchange: $69.99. |
| Costco, Tractor Supply, Ace | Refill | Not posted online | Set by each store. Ask for the per-gallon price and multiply by 4.7. |
| Walmart, Home Depot, Lowe's, gas stations | Exchange | Not posted online | Blue Rhino or AmeriGas cages. Both brands cut their fill from 17 lb to 15 lb in 2008, which the FTC alleged was a disguised price rise (settled 2014). |
| Local propane dealer | Refill | Not posted online | Many fill cylinders at the yard. Ring for the per-gallon price. |
How we priced this: U-Haul "Propane near" results pages for 20 metros (for example Dallas), every location price listed at propanetankrefillcost.com; Blue Rhino Delivery+; FTC matter 111-0195. Read 18 November 2026, prices before sales tax. A full 20 lb tank is taken as 4.7 gallons (20 lb at about 4.24 lb a gallon), so a fill = 4.7 x the per-gallon price.
How Long Does a 20 lb Tank Last?
A full tank holds about 430,000 BTU (20 lb x 21,548 BTU per pound, PERC pocket guide). Hours = 430,000 / your appliance's BTU rating. Burners on medium draw less, so they last longer than these full-output times.
Buying a Tank
Blue Rhino Delivery+ lists a filled spare tank with no exchange at $69.99 plus tax (read 18 November 2026). Hardware and home stores sell empty tanks and pre-filled exchange tanks at prices set store by store. An empty tank needs a refill before first use; at the U-Haul median that adds about $20.92.
When buying new: check that the valve is OPD-compliant (required since 2002). Look for the triangular handwheel on the valve - that indicates OPD compliance.
20 lb Tank Expiration and Recertification
Every propane tank has a manufacture date stamped on the collar (the metal ring at the top). This date is in MM/YY format - for example, "04/13" means April 2013. Tanks expire 12 years after this date and cannot be refilled until recertified.
| Recertification Stage | When | Where |
|---|---|---|
| First recertification | 12 years after manufacture date | Propane dealers that requalify cylinders (ask their charge first) |
| Subsequent recertifications | Every 5 years after first recert | Same as above |
| Tank replacement | If recertification fails or costs more than a new tank | Exchange cages take the old tank |
If your tank is near expiration, the exchange program is a smart option - they accept expired tanks and give you a freshly recertified one. Just be aware you are paying more per pound of propane for that convenience.
Tips to Save on 20 lb Propane
Refill stations charge by the gallon. U-Haul's posted prices ran from $3.75 to $5.80 a gallon, so it pays to compare two or three nearby.
Unless your tank is out of date, a refill puts in 20 lb; an exchange tank holds 15 lb.
Keeping 2 tanks means you can refill both at once and never run out mid-cook. Buy when on sale at season start.
If a tank is near empty (close to TW on collar), you will get more value from a full refill than topping off.