PropaneCostPerGallon.com is an independent resource. We are not a propane supplier, and no supplier can pay to change our prices. Prices are estimates based on EIA data.

Propane vs Heating Oil: Which Is Cheaper for Home Heating? (2026)

Northeast-focused comparison on EIA's weekly residential prices: propane $3.24 vs heating oil $4.91 per 100,000 BTU delivered. System efficiency and your state's prices decide which wins for your home.

Latest EIA residential propane price

Source: EIA SHOPP residential propane survey. Week ending 16 November 2026. Refreshed 19 November 2026.

Could a supplier near you beat your price?

The US average is $2.82 a gallon (EIA). Tell us your ZIP and tank size and we'll ask local suppliers to quote you. Compare with your last bill. Free, no obligation.

Get my free quotes →

Propane vs Heating Oil: Full Comparison (2026)

FactorPropaneHeating Oil (No.2)Winner
Price per gallon (latest EIA)$2.82 (US avg)$5.92 (US avg)Propane
BTU per gallon91,500 BTU138,500 BTUHeating Oil
Max system efficiency (AFUE)98% (condensing)95% (condensing oil)Propane
Typical system efficiency90-96% AFUE82-90% AFUEPropane
Cost per 100k BTU (95% / 87% AFUE)$3.24$4.91Propane
CO2 emissions per MMBtu139 lbs161 lbsPropane
Sulfur dioxide emissionsNegligibleModeratePropane
Spill/environmental riskVapor dispersesSoil contamination riskPropane
Price volatilityModerate (domestic supply)High (crude oil linked)Propane
AvailabilityAll 50 statesPrimarily NortheastPropane
Tank neededYes (above or underground)Yes (above ground typical)Tie

The BTU Math: Why Price Per Gallon Is Misleading

Heating oil contains 138,500 BTU per gallon vs propane's 91,500 BTU per gallon. This is why you cannot compare fuel prices by the gallon alone. You need to compare cost per unit of heat delivered.

The Full Calculation (latest EIA national averages)
Propane: $2.82/gal / 91,500 BTU x 100,000 = $3.08 raw per 100k BTU
Propane at 95% AFUE: $3.08 / 0.95 = $3.24 per 100k BTU delivered
Heating Oil: $5.92/gal / 138,500 BTU x 100,000 = $4.27 raw per 100k BTU
Heating oil at 87% AFUE: $4.27 / 0.87 = $4.91 per 100k BTU delivered
Result: At these national averages, propane delivers heat about 34% more cheaply: propane $3.24 vs heating oil $4.91 per 100k BTU. It varies by state (table below).
Prices: EIA residential propane, week ending 16 November 2026; EIA residential No. 2 heating oil, week of 9 November 2026; both exclude taxes. A home heated mainly by propane used 656 gallons on average in 2020 (EIA RECS 2020, table CE2.1), so multiply your own yearly gallons by these prices to compare bills.

Northeast State-by-State: Propane vs Heating Oil (2026)

This comparison matters most in the Northeast where both fuels are widely used. Costs per 100k BTU based on typical system efficiencies (propane 95% AFUE, oil 87% AFUE).

StatePropane $/galHeating Oil $/galPropane /100k BTUOil /100k BTUCheaper Fuel
Connecticut$4.41$5.67$5.08$4.70Heating Oil
Maine$3.68$5.83$4.24$4.84Propane
Massachusetts$3.82$5.96$4.39$4.95Propane
New Hampshire$3.90$5.93$4.48$4.92Propane
Rhode Island$4.12$5.96$4.74$4.94Propane
Vermont$3.99$5.81$4.59$4.82Propane
New York$3.82$6.14$4.40$5.10Propane
Pennsylvania$3.27$5.71$3.76$4.74Propane

Source: EIA weekly residential prices excluding taxes, propane week ending 16 November 2026 and No. 2 heating oil week of 9 November 2026 (EIA heating oil table). Efficiencies assumed: propane 95% AFUE, oil 87% AFUE.

Propane vs Heating Oil FAQ

Is propane or heating oil cheaper in 2026?
On EIA's latest residential prices, propane at $2.82 a gallon (week ending 16 November 2026) and No. 2 heating oil at $5.92 a gallon (week of 9 November 2026) work out at $3.24 and $4.91 per 100,000 BTU of heat delivered, assuming a 95% AFUE propane furnace and an 87% AFUE oil boiler. Propane is about 34% cheaper per unit of heat at those prices. Heating oil carries more energy per gallon (138,500 BTU against 91,500), so compare the cost per BTU, not the price per gallon, and use your own suppliers' prices and your system's efficiency.
Is propane cleaner than heating oil?
Yes, propane burns significantly cleaner than heating oil. Propane produces approximately 139 lbs of CO2 per million BTU, compared to 161 lbs for heating oil - about 14% less. Propane also produces minimal sulfur dioxide, particulate matter, and other pollutants compared to oil. Bioheat blends (heating oil with up to 20% biodiesel) reduce oil's emissions but still do not match propane's cleanliness.
How much does it cost to switch from heating oil to propane?
A whole-home switch has four parts: removing or abandoning the oil tank, a propane tank and the gas line to the house, a propane furnace or boiler (some boilers can take a propane burner instead of being replaced), and converting any other appliances. The tank is the only part with published prices we could read: Tankfarm, which installs in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Rhode Island and parts of New Hampshire, lists complete above-ground packages from $2,444 for a 120-gallon tank to $7,825 for 1,000 gallons, including 25 feet of gas line (checked October 20, 2026). Get written quotes for the rest, and compare the cost per 100,000 BTU in the table on this page using your own fuel prices before deciding.
Which is safer to store: propane or heating oil?
Heating oil has a higher safety margin in some respects: it will not ignite unless heated above 140F, so a spilled puddle will not ignite from a spark the way propane vapor can. However, an oil spill contaminates soil and can be expensive to clean up. Propane leaks dissipate into the air and leave no environmental residue. Both fuels are safe with proper installation and maintenance. Propane requires pressure containment; oil requires spill containment.
Propane vs Electric|Northeast state prices|Boiler replacement costs

Spotted an out-of-date price, or have a propane question?

A real person reads every message. Tell us if something on this page looks wrong, or ask anything about propane pricing, tanks, or suppliers.

Ask us or flag a correction

Or email questions@propanecostpergallon.com. With your permission we may publish an anonymised version of your question and our answer. General information, not professional advice.

How this site is paid for: when you ask for quotes, we pass your request to up to three local suppliers, and they may pay us for the introduction. Our prices and dealer listings do not depend on that. They come from EIA and state sources, and no supplier can pay to change them.